...that I sadly haven't photographed yet. Tonight, perhaps.
Last year, I picked up a bag of red silk hankies, about 25 grams; on Wednesday, I finally cracked into it. The things have a bit of a reputation, and I found parts of what I'd heard held up, and parts of it didn't.
1) The damn things will cling to anything - True! To prepare for spinning, I filed my nails, lotioned my hands, and used the nail file on a patch of rough skin from a scab that just fell off - yes, that translates to "I sanded my hand"! It didn't help. There were apparently still microscopic rough patches that stray fibers wanted to grab. They snagged on my hands. They clung to each other. They snagged on the carved part of my spindle shaft. They snagged on the plastic baggie. They snagged on my clothes. They snagged on, as far as I could tell, the air. For the love of Pete don't let the cat near the pile of undrafted hankies.
2) Drafting them will cut up your hands - True! I used the "Poke a hole, pull into a loop, break when it's thin enough" method. My index fingers and thumbs felt slightly abraded the next day, as though there were a bajillion microscopic lacerations on them. That's because there were - a single strand of silk is insanely thin and insanely strong and when you draft, you have to essentially pull the world's teeniest cable saw across your fingers. You also have to pull pretty hard; if you're used to drafting smooth wool top this will feel like a workout. (Someone on Ravelry reported good results with both snag prevention and abrasion resistance wearing thin latex gloves while she spun. I didn't have any to try this with.)
3) The yield is not very good - not so true! I think I'm getting 4-5 yards out of a hankie that comes off the stack mostly intact, and I think there's 40-50 hankies in my stack. (For some reason I'd figured there'd be 7 or 8. I have no idea what I was thinking.) This is similar yardage to what I got from silk top, although I might have been spinning that a little thicker. We'll have to see what I end up with when I'm all done. (Spinning combed top was much
faster - it took me about 15 minutes to draft and spin each hankie, and probably only about 4 or 5 to make an equivalent amount of yarn from top. But then again I'm new at this.)
4) You can't draft it further once you've started to spin - not so true! The deal is, you just have to remember the staple length is something like a foot; hold your hands really far apart, and pull hard. Also, catch problems before they happen. Thinning out a thick spot that didn't have any twist in it yet was no harder than drafting the hankie in the first place, but I think that would have changed with even a teeny bit of twist.
5) You will get a noily, slubby yarn - True! The edges of the hankies are a bit lumpy, and as someone else pointed out, if the cocoons your hankies were made from were perfect, they would have been reeled instead. Plus, while you can draft it on the spindle, you really
can't use the method I was taught for correcting a thick spot (untwist it, draft it, let the twist back in - in theory you could still do this, but you'd have to untwist a foot of yarn that you put a lot of twist into), which makes slubs. So the yarn will be kind of rustic - but OMG is it soft and lustrous.
6) Once you've got the hankies drafted, you can't screw up the spinning - pretty much true! I think even an absolute newbie would be hard-pressed to put too much twist in, and joins are easy as pie. Highly recommended for a beginner who wants to spin silk but is afraid of slippery fibers.
Halfway through the second hankie, I was about ready to give up because of all the snagging - I have a
pusher spinning supply shop nearby, and she'll sell me all the
spinning crack silk top I want. Unsurprisingly, the more I did it, the better I got at it, and the more I liked it. We'll have to see how it's going at the end of the process - I've barely made a dent in the hankie pile.